🤖 Beep-boop. I can read reviews REALLY FAST and summarize. Do you have any questions about Broil King Baron or Napoleon Rogue 425?
Cooking Area
Burners
Material
Features
Maintenance
Warranty
Expand Hide

Neither Broil King Baron nor Napoleon Rogue 425 were recommended by experts this month

On 1 Nov 2024 (1 month ago) we went through 64 Gas Grill expert endorsements , however neither Broil King Baron nor Napoleon Rogue 425 were included in any of those recommendations. Since neither Gas Grill received a single endorsement, as far as expert recommendations go, it's technically a tie. We do, however, recommend taking a look at Weber Spirit II E-310 or other critically acclaimed Gas Grills of this month.

For reference, Weber Spirit II E-310 received 6 endorsements this month, from Business Insider (12 Aug 2024), Homes & Gardens (11 Jul 2024) Good Housekeeping (20 Jul 2021) and 3 others.

Rank Change Price Gas Grill
Food & Wine
Business Insider
Homes & Gardens
Good Housekeeping
NBC News
Popular Mechanics
Forbes
Bob Vila
CNET
Wirecutter
1
- $569
Weber Spirit II E-310
The Weber Spirit II E-310 Gas Grill is a versatile and durable outdoor cooking appliance with ample cooking space, even heat distribution, and easy maintenance, making it ideal for frequent grillers.
-
1
2
3
3
-
1
-
-
1
N/A N/A $499
Broil King Baron
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
N/A N/A Check price
Napoleon Rogue 425
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-

Curious to see this month's entire Gas Grills ranking? It's here

About our ranking methodology

MetaRanking Common points from expert reviews summarized.
As can be seen below, in Nov 2024 neither Broil King Baron nor Napoleon Rogue 425 were recommended by key experts who publish Gas Grills recommendations.
Rank Change Price Gas Grill
Food & Wine
Business Insider
Homes & Gardens
Good Housekeeping
NBC News
Popular Mechanics
Forbes
Bob Vila
CNET
Wirecutter
1
- $569
Weber Spirit II E-310
The Weber Spirit II E-310 Gas Grill is a versatile and durable outdoor cooking appliance with ample cooking space, even heat distribution, and easy maintenance, making it ideal for frequent grillers.
-
1
2
3
3
-
1
-
-
1
2
- $539
Weber Spirit II E-210
The Weber Spirit II E-210 gas grill is a durable and high-quality option for small outdoor spaces, with convenient features and easy maintenance.
-
2
-
-
-
1
-
1
-
3
3
- $1468
Weber Genesis Smart EX-335
The Genesis II EX-335 Gas Grill is a versatile and durable outdoor cooking appliance with high-performing heating and searing capabilities, easy maintenance, and an impressive 10-year warranty.
-
3
-
1
-
-
-
-
-
-
4
- $250
Coleman RoadTrip 285
The Coleman RoadTrip 285 Gas Grill is a versatile and durable portable grill with a large cooking area, adjustable burners, and easy-to-clean features, making it an excellent investment for outdoor activities, camping, and tailgating.
-
-
-
5
5
-
5
-
-
-
Show all rows
Expert Reviews There are people on the Internet whose job is to review products. Below are their opinions.

Expert reviews [11]

83
Total expert reviews: 11
  • with a score: 4
  • without a score: 7
Highest score by T3
100
Average score based on 11 reviews
83
Lowest score by CNET
67

Score distribution:

80-100
60-80
40-60
20-40
0-20
92
The Broil King Baron 440 is a reliable and affordable gas grill that offers a great grilling experience. While it may not be the fastest-heating or most spacious grill, it cooks meat evenly and thoroughly with its cast-iron grates and patented cooking system.
+ pros
  • Cooks meat evenly and thoroughly with cast-iron grates that lock in heat.
  • Sturdy construction with durable materials.
  • Compact size for easy storage in tight areas.
  • Comes with all the essential features and some extras.
  • Optional rotisserie kit for roasting meat while grilling.
- cons
  • Slower to heat up than some other grills in the lineup.
  • Smaller cooking space than most other grills.
  • Meat has a tendency to stick at high temperatures.
67
The Broil King Baron S520 is a large, powerful gas grill with five burners and a simple, understated design. It runs hot and lacks features, making it best suited for experienced grillers who prioritize power over extras.
+ pros
  • Powerful: The Broil King Baron S520 has a lot of power, making it great for cooking large amounts of food at once.
  • Easy to control: The grill is easy to light, control, and maintain, making it user-friendly for experienced grillers.
  • Even cooking: The ridged metal plates above the burners distribute heat well, resulting in even cooking.
- cons
  • Runs hot: The grill runs hot, which can be intimidating for beginners and may result in burnt food if not monitored closely.
  • Lacks features: The grill doesn't have many features, such as side burners or smart temperature gauges, which may be a drawback for some users.
  • Expensive: At $650, the Broil King Baron S520 is a pricier option compared to other grills with similar features.
Show all 11 reviews

Expert reviews [10]

78
Total expert reviews: 10
  • with a score: 2
  • without a score: 8
Highest score by derrickriches.com
86
Average score based on 10 reviews
78
Lowest score by livingetc.com
70

Score distribution:

80-100
60-80
40-60
20-40
0-20
The Napoleon Rogue 425 SIB is a well-built, mid-to-small size gas grill with three main burners and a high heat side infrared burner. It has quality construction, convenient features, and cooks food well, making it a great addition to any patio or deck at a reasonable price.
+ pros
  • Robust and well thought out packaging for easy assembly.
  • Convenient use of same size hex head machine screw for assembly.
  • Cross light brackets add safety to the JETFIRETM igniting system.
  • 9mm stainless steel wave cooking grate is easy to clean.
  • Reasonably affordable price for a high quality compact gas grill.
- cons
  • SIZZLE ZONETM side burner may cause food to burn and is prone to flare ups with fatty meats.
  • Pressure applied to gas feed line when folding down side shelf and burner may displace grommet protecting gas line.
  • Propane tank stability ring is flimsy and lacks a fuel level indicator.
  • Temperature consistency is not great, with a 50 degree difference from front to back of grill.
The mobile app allows users to search, save, and sort their favorite recipes, making it easy to access them offline. It is a convenient tool for anyone who loves cooking and wants to have their go-to recipes at their fingertips.
+ pros
  • Ability to search, save, and sort favourite recipes for easy access.
  • Offline viewing of saved recipes for convenience.
- cons
  • No mention of recipe recommendations or personalized suggestions.
  • No indication of community features for sharing and discovering new recipes.
Show all 10 reviews
From Seller:
  • This product is a Natural Gas unit and you must have Natural Gas plumbed out to your patio or deck to be able to use this grill; If you do not have Natural Gas plumbed, please look at our selection of Propane barbecues
  • Read more
From Seller:
  • This product is a Natural Gas unit and you must have Natural Gas plumbed out to your patio or deck to be able to use this grill; If you do not have Natural Gas plumbed, please look at our selection of Propane barbecues
  • Read more

This website displays data from third party public sources. The data presented is for information purposes only. We can't guarantee correctness and completeness of all the data presented here, and therefore will not accept liability for any issues arising from usage of this data. All Trademarks and Copyrights belong to their respective owners. ReviewFinder is reader-supported - if you click on a link on ReviewFinder and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you.


Copyright © 2024