Napoleon Rogue 425 vs Weber Spirit E310: Overview of expert opinions
The Napoleon Rogue 425 is better for those who prioritize power, searing ability, and a larger cooking area. It is a great option for those who enjoy cooking larger cuts of meat or entertaining guests with a variety of dishes. The high-top lid design allows for more space, and the option to expand the cooking area with accessories makes it a versatile choice.
The stainless steel cooking grids and unique design contribute to even cooking and consistent results, and the SIZZLE ZONETM high heat side infrared burner is perfect for intense searing. The removable condiment caddy and drip pan make cleaning and organization easier.
The Weber Spirit E310 is better for larger families or those who like to entertain guests, as it has a larger total cooking area. The foldable steel tables on the sides make it a convenient choice for those who like to have everything they need within reach while cooking. The porcelain-enameled cast iron grates are ideal for those who want a non-stick surface for delicate foods like fish and vegetables, and the built-in fuel gauge and warming rack are useful features.
The grease management system funnels grease away from the burners and into a removable tray, making cleaning and maintenance easier. The 10-year warranty covers all grill components without any specific exclusions or limitations mentioned.
Table of contents (click on an item)
Cooking Area
The Napoleon Rogue 425 is better for those who prioritize power and searing ability, as it has a higher BTU output and can heat up faster. It is also a good option for those who enjoy cooking larger cuts of meat or entertaining guests with a variety of dishes, as the high-top lid design allows for more space.
Additionally, the option to expand the cooking area with accessories such as a warming rack or side burner makes it a versatile choice.
The Weber Spirit E310, on the other hand, is better for larger families or those who like to entertain guests, as it has a larger total cooking area. The foldable steel tables on the sides also make it a convenient choice for those who like to have everything they need within reach while cooking.
The porcelain-enameled cast iron grates are ideal for those who want a non-stick surface for delicate foods like fish and vegetables, and the built-in fuel gauge and warming rack are useful features. However, it may not be as suitable for camping or tailgating due to its larger size.
Burners
The Napoleon Rogue 425 is better for those who prioritize a larger cooking area, durable construction, and additional features such as a built-in thermometer, side burner, and rotisserie kit. It is a great choice for larger families or those who like to entertain. The higher total power output of 42,000 BTUs also makes it a better choice for those who prioritize power and searing ability.
On the other hand, the Weber Spirit E310 is better for those who prioritize affordability, compact size, power, quality, and durability. With a power output of over 10,000 BTUs per burner, it can still provide enough heat for most grilling needs. It is a strong contender for those who want to save time and energy while grilling and want a reliable and efficient grill that can handle a variety of cooking tasks.
Its porcelain enameled cast iron grates are designed to distribute heat evenly across the cooking surface, making it a great choice for those who like to cook a variety of foods on their grill.
Overall, both grills have similar features, but the Napoleon Rogue 425 is better for those who prioritize a larger cooking area, durability, and additional features, while the Weber Spirit E310 is better for those who prioritize affordability, compact size, power, quality, and durability.
Material
The Napoleon Rogue 425 is better for those who prioritize even cooking and consistent results due to its stainless steel cooking grids in a wave pattern and unique design that includes stainless steel sear plates that distribute heat evenly across the cooking surface. It is also more durable than the Weber Spirit E310 and won't rust or corrode over time.
The high-grade stainless steel used for the lid of the Napoleon Rogue 425 also contributes to its durability and ability to maintain a consistent temperature inside the grill.
The Weber Spirit E310, on the other hand, is better for those who prioritize speed and cooking capacity due to its higher BTU output and larger cooking surface. The porcelain-enameled cast iron grates heat evenly and retain heat well, making it a great option for those who want their food to stay warm for longer after it's been removed from the grill.
The heavy-duty porcelain-enameled lid and cookbox, as well as porcelain-enameled cast iron cooking grates and stainless steel burners, also contribute to its durability and longevity.
Overall, both grills are made of high-quality materials and are built to last. The choice between the two will ultimately come down to personal preference and specific grilling needs.
Features
The Napoleon Rogue 425 is better for those who prioritize intense searing of meats and vegetables, as it has a unique SIZZLE ZONETM high heat side infrared burner. It also has a removable condiment caddy for convenient storage of sauces, spices, and other grilling accessories.
The wide range of accessories available also allows for customization of the grill to individual preferences.
The Weber Spirit E310 is better for those who need to cook for larger groups, as it has a larger cooking area. It also has a larger and more versatile warming rack that can be used to toast buns, warm tortillas, or heat up side dishes. The foldable steel tables on the sides, electronic ignition system, front-mounted thermometer, and enclosed cart with smooth-rolling casters make it a convenient and practical choice for any grilling enthusiast.
The grease management system also makes cleaning up after grilling easier.
Overall, the Napoleon Rogue 425 is better for those who prioritize intense searing and customization, while the Weber Spirit E310 is better for those who need to cook for larger groups and prioritize convenience and ease of use.
Maintenance
The Napoleon Rogue 425 is better for those who prioritize cooking performance and ease of cleaning, as its stainless steel cooking grids provide better heat retention and easier cleaning compared to the Weber Spirit E310's porcelain-enameled cast iron cooking grates. Additionally, the Rogue 425's removable condiment caddy and drip pan make cleaning and organization easier.
It is a good choice for those who want a durable and long-lasting grill that is easy to maintain.
The Weber Spirit E310 is better for those who prioritize ease of maintenance and cleaning, as its grease management system funnels grease away from the burners and into a removable tray, which can be easily emptied and cleaned. The Spirit E310 also offers the option of using disposable foil trays for even easier cleaning.
It is a good choice for those who want a low maintenance grill that is easy to clean and use. However, its heavy-duty construction and size may require more effort for cleaning and maintenance.
Warranty
Based on the expert reviews, the Napoleon Rogue 425 is better for those who want a longer warranty period for specific parts such as stainless steel tube burners and sear plates. However, buyers should be aware of the specific exclusions and limitations in the warranty terms and conditions.
On the other hand, the Weber Spirit E310 is better for those who want a simpler warranty that covers all grill components for 10 years without any specific exclusions or limitations mentioned. Overall, buyers should carefully review the warranty terms and conditions of each product before making a purchase decision based on their specific needs and preferences.
Neither Napoleon Rogue 425 nor Weber Spirit E310 were recommended by experts this month
On 1 Nov 2024 (1 month ago) we went through 64 Gas Grill expert endorsements , however neither Napoleon Rogue 425 nor Weber Spirit E310 were included in any of those recommendations. Since neither Gas Grill received a single endorsement, as far as expert recommendations go, it's technically a tie. We do, however, recommend taking a look at Weber Spirit II E-310 or other critically acclaimed Gas Grills of this month.
For reference, Weber Spirit II E-310 received 6 endorsements this month, from Business Insider (12 Aug 2024), Homes & Gardens (11 Jul 2024) Good Housekeeping (20 Jul 2021) and 3 others.
Rank | Change | Price | Gas Grill | Food & Wine | Business Insider | Homes & Gardens | Good Housekeeping | NBC News | Popular Mechanics | Forbes
| Bob Vila | CNET | Wirecutter |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | - | $569 | Weber Spirit II E-310 The Weber Spirit II E-310 Gas Grill is a versatile and durable outdoor cooking appliance with ample cooking space, even heat distribution, and easy maintenance, making it ideal for frequent grillers. | - | 1 | 2 | 3 | 3 | - | 1 | - | - | 1 |
N/A | N/A | Check price | Napoleon Rogue 425 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
N/A | N/A | $903 | Weber Spirit E310 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
Curious to see this month's entire Gas Grills ranking? It's here
Rank | Change | Price | Gas Grill | Food & Wine | Business Insider | Homes & Gardens | Good Housekeeping | NBC News | Popular Mechanics | Forbes | Bob Vila | CNET | Wirecutter |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | - | $569 | Weber Spirit II E-310 The Weber Spirit II E-310 Gas Grill is a versatile and durable outdoor cooking appliance with ample cooking space, even heat distribution, and easy maintenance, making it ideal for frequent grillers. | - | 1 | 2 | 3 | 3 | - | 1 | - | - | 1 |
2 | - | $539 | Weber Spirit II E-210 The Weber Spirit II E-210 gas grill is a durable and high-quality option for small outdoor spaces, with convenient features and easy maintenance. | - | 2 | - | - | - | 1 | - | 1 | - | 3 |
3 | - | $1468 | Weber Genesis Smart EX-335 The Genesis II EX-335 Gas Grill is a versatile and durable outdoor cooking appliance with high-performing heating and searing capabilities, easy maintenance, and an impressive 10-year warranty. | - | 3 | - | 1 | - | - | - | - | - | - |
4 | - | $250 | Coleman RoadTrip 285 The Coleman RoadTrip 285 Gas Grill is a versatile and durable portable grill with a large cooking area, adjustable burners, and easy-to-clean features, making it an excellent investment for outdoor activities, camping, and tailgating. | - | - | - | 5 | 5 | - | 5 | - | - | - |
Show all rows |
Expert reviews [10]
- with a score: 2
- without a score: 8
Highest score by derrickriches.com | 86 |
Average score based on 10 reviews | 78 |
Lowest score by livingetc.com | 70 |
Score distribution:
80-100 | |
60-80 | |
40-60 | |
20-40 | |
0-20 |
- Robust and well thought out packaging for easy assembly.
- Convenient use of same size hex head machine screw for assembly.
- Cross light brackets add safety to the JETFIRETM igniting system.
- 9mm stainless steel wave cooking grate is easy to clean.
- Reasonably affordable price for a high quality compact gas grill.
- SIZZLE ZONETM side burner may cause food to burn and is prone to flare ups with fatty meats.
- Pressure applied to gas feed line when folding down side shelf and burner may displace grommet protecting gas line.
- Propane tank stability ring is flimsy and lacks a fuel level indicator.
- Temperature consistency is not great, with a 50 degree difference from front to back of grill.
- Ability to search, save, and sort favourite recipes for easy access.
- Offline viewing of saved recipes for convenience.
- No mention of recipe recommendations or personalized suggestions.
- No indication of community features for sharing and discovering new recipes.
Expert reviews [5]
- with a score: 2
- without a score: 3
Highest score by theonlinegrill.com | 100 |
Average score based on 5 reviews | 98 |
Lowest score by thegrillinglife.com | 95 |
Score distribution:
80-100 | |
60-80 | |
40-60 | |
20-40 | |
0-20 |
- High powered and efficient grill with innovative features such as the iGrill application.
- Open cart design with side panels for extra space and convenience.
- Sturdy and durable with cast-iron cooking grates and a grease management system.
- Even heat distribution and large cooking surface for catering to more people in less time.
- Easy to start up and maintain with minimal cleaning required.
- Comes with a 10-year warranty from a reliable brand.
- Not suitable for cooking larger items such as a whole chicken.
- Handle and body can get very hot during cooking, requiring the use of oven mitts.
- Generous grilling space and consistent temperature control for great BBQ results.
- Porcelain-enameled lid with a center-mounted thermometer, painted steel door, and ample storage space.
- Large stainless steel work surfaces, front-mounted knobs and valves, and an electronic ignition system.
- Porcelain enameled cast iron grates heat evenly and sear foods beautifully.
- Three stainless steel burners that put out 32,000 BTU-per-hour and 529 square inches of total cooking area.
- Porcelain-enameled Flavorizer bars that vaporize falling juices, creating flavorful smoke that provides your food with that great BBQ taste.
- Positive feedback from many satisfied owners and a 4.5 out of 5-star rating on Amazon.
- More expensive than many other well-known grill brands.
- This product is a Natural Gas unit and you must have Natural Gas plumbed out to your patio or deck to be able to use this grill; If you do not have Natural Gas plumbed, please look at our selection of Propane barbecues
- Read more
- This product is a Natural Gas unit and you must have Natural Gas plumbed out to your patio or deck to be able to use this grill; If you do not have Natural Gas plumbed, please look at our selection of Propane barbecues
- Read more