Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 vs Withings ScanWatch: Overview of expert opinions

Both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and the Withings ScanWatch have a comprehensive set of fitness tracking features. However, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 has a wider range of features, including automatic workout detection for over 90 exercises, built-in sleep tracking with personalized sleep programs, and a Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis sensor that provides a thorough body composition analysis.

The Galaxy Watch 5 also has an ECG app for A-fib detection, which the Withings ScanWatch does not have. This feature is particularly useful for people with heart conditions or those who want to monitor their heart health closely. The ECG app can detect irregular heart rhythms and alert the user to seek medical attention if necessary.

On the other hand, the Withings ScanWatch has a good range of sport profiles and supports auto-tracking for walking, running, swimming, and biking. It also provides good enough data to monitor progress and see where you’re lagging and where you’re improving. This is particularly useful for people who want to track their fitness goals and see how they are progressing over time.

Overall, both watches are great options for fitness tracking, but the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 has a wider range of features. It is particularly useful for people who want to monitor their heart health closely or those who want a more comprehensive analysis of their body composition.

The Withings ScanWatch, on the other hand, is a good option for people who want to track their fitness goals and see how they are progressing over time.

Both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and the Withings ScanWatch offer accurate heart rate monitoring capabilities. However, the Withings ScanWatch offers continuous heart rate tracking every 10 minutes, which means that it can provide more detailed insights into your heart rate throughout the day and night.

On the other hand, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 offers high and low heart rate alerts, as well as fall detection during workouts, which can be useful for those who engage in physical activity. Additionally, the Galaxy Watch 5 can check for irregular heart rate rhythms through an on-demand ECG, while the Withings ScanWatch does not have this feature.

Ultimately, the choice between these two smartwatches will depend on your specific needs and preferences. If you prioritize continuous heart rate tracking and detailed insights, the Withings ScanWatch may be the better option for you. However, if you are more focused on physical activity and want features like fall detection and irregular heart rate rhythm checks, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 may be the better choice.

It's important to consider your individual needs and priorities when choosing a smartwatch for heart rate monitoring.

In terms of GPS capabilities, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 has a clear advantage over the Withings ScanWatch as it has built-in GPS. This means that users can track their outdoor activities without needing to bring their phone along. On the other hand, the Withings ScanWatch requires users to connect their watch to their phone's GPS to track outdoor activities.

However, it's worth noting that the Withings ScanWatch has other features that the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 doesn't have, such as ECG monitoring and sleep apnea detection. Ultimately, the choice between the two watches will depend on the user's specific needs and preferences.

If GPS tracking is a top priority, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 may be the better option. However, if ECG monitoring and sleep apnea detection are important features, the Withings ScanWatch may be the better choice. It's important to consider all of the features and capabilities of each watch before making a decision.

In terms of smart assistant integration, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 clearly has an advantage over the Withings ScanWatch. The Galaxy Watch 5 features both Bixby and Google Assistant, allowing users to choose their preferred assistant. Additionally, the Galaxy Watch 5 has access to Google-developed apps, including Google Assistant, Maps, and Messages, which can be seamlessly used on the watch.

This means that users can easily access their favorite apps and services without having to switch between devices. On the other hand, the Withings ScanWatch does not have a built-in smart assistant, which means it does not support voice commands or integration with virtual assistants.

This can be a drawback for users who rely on smart assistants for tasks such as setting reminders, sending messages, or making phone calls. Therefore, if smart assistant integration is an important feature for you, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 would be the better choice. With its support for both Bixby and Google Assistant, as well as access to a wide range of Google-developed apps, the Galaxy Watch 5 offers a more comprehensive smart assistant experience.

When comparing the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and the Withings ScanWatch, it is clear that both smartwatches have unique features that set them apart from each other.

The Galaxy Watch 5 has advanced sleep coaching, body composition analysis, improved sensor accuracy, auto workout tracking, enhanced GPS, sapphire crystal glass, and a Galaxy connected experience.

On the other hand, the Withings ScanWatch has a traditional watch design, long battery life, advanced health monitoring capabilities, water-resistance, comprehensive fitness tracking, and smartphone notifications.

One of the most significant differences between the two watches is their focus. The Galaxy Watch 5 is geared towards fitness enthusiasts who want to track their workouts and overall wellness. It has advanced features like body composition analysis and auto workout tracking that make it an excellent choice for people who want to monitor their fitness progress.

The Withings ScanWatch, on the other hand, is more focused on health monitoring. It has advanced features like ECG monitoring, blood oxygen level assessment, and respiratory scans during sleep that make it an excellent choice for people who want to monitor their health.

Another significant difference between the two watches is their design. The Galaxy Watch 5 has a modern, sleek design that looks great on the wrist. It has a large, colorful display that is easy to read, and it comes in a variety of colors and styles.

The Withings ScanWatch, on the other hand, has a more traditional watch design with physical hour and minute hands. It looks more like a classic timepiece than a smartwatch, which may appeal to people who want a watch that looks more like a traditional watch.

In terms of battery life, the Withings ScanWatch has a clear advantage. It has a battery life of up to 30 days between charges, which is significantly longer than the Galaxy Watch 5's battery life. This makes it an excellent choice for people who don't want to worry about charging their watch every day.

Overall, both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and the Withings ScanWatch are excellent smartwatches with unique features that set them apart from each other. The Galaxy Watch 5 is geared towards fitness enthusiasts who want to track their workouts and overall wellness, while the Withings ScanWatch is more focused on health monitoring.

The Galaxy Watch 5 has a modern, sleek design, while the Withings ScanWatch has a more traditional watch design. Ultimately, the choice between the two watches will depend on your individual needs and preferences.

In terms of battery life, the Withings ScanWatch has a clear advantage over the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5. While the Samsung watch can last up to 50 hours with limited usage, the Withings watch can last up to 30 days with normal usage.

This means that the Withings watch requires less frequent charging and is more convenient for users who don't want to worry about running out of battery during the day. However, it's important to note that the actual battery life of both watches may vary depending on usage and features enabled.

In terms of charging time, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 appears to be faster than the Withings ScanWatch. The Galaxy Watch 5 can be charged to 100% in just over an hour, while the ScanWatch takes two hours to fully charge.

Additionally, the Galaxy Watch 5 supports faster charging with a more powerful adapter, which can be useful for those who need to quickly charge their watch on the go. This feature can be particularly beneficial for individuals who lead busy lifestyles and need their watch to be fully charged at all times.

However, it is important to note that the charging time may vary depending on the charging adapter used for both watches. It is recommended to use the original charging adapter that comes with the watch to ensure optimal charging performance.

Overall, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 appears to have an advantage in terms of charging time and convenience, but it is important to consider other factors such as battery life and overall functionality when choosing a smartwatch.

Both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and Withings ScanWatch have power-saving modes to extend battery life. However, there is a significant difference between the two in terms of how long their power-saving modes can last.

The Withings ScanWatch's power-saving mode can last up to an additional 20 days, which is a considerable amount of time. This is because the watch's power-saving mode turns off most of its features, including the heart rate monitor and notifications. This means that the watch can still tell time and track steps, but it won't be able to do much else.

On the other hand, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5's power-saving mode only limits functionality to extend battery life. This means that the watch will still be able to receive notifications and track fitness data, but some features may be disabled or limited. The battery life extension may not be as significant as the Withings ScanWatch's power-saving mode, but it still provides some extra time before needing to be charged.

Ultimately, the choice between the two watches will depend on individual preferences and priorities. For those who prioritize battery life over functionality, the Withings ScanWatch may be the better option. However, for those who want to maintain some functionality while extending battery life, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 may be the better choice.

Both watches have features that can significantly drain the battery faster, especially when used extensively.

For the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5, using it for workouts and leaving it in airplane mode can drain the battery faster, while having the Always On Display (AOD) enabled can also contribute to battery drain.

On the other hand, the Withings ScanWatch can experience battery drain when using features such as SpO2 and ECG monitoring, respiratory scan at night, and blood oxygen level monitoring, as well as enabling more notifications and using connected GPS for frequent runs.

It's important to note that not all features are turned on by default, so adjusting settings to suit your needs and lifestyle can help conserve battery life on both watches.

Both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and Withings ScanWatch can have their battery life affected by the type of activities or workouts being tracked. However, the Withings ScanWatch seems to have a longer battery life even with regular use of GPS and workout tracking. On the other hand, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 may drain faster if used for intense workouts and frequent notifications.

This is because the watch has a larger and more vibrant display, which requires more power to operate. Additionally, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 has more features and apps that can also contribute to battery drain. Overall, both watches have decent battery life and can last for several days with moderate use.

However, if you plan on using your watch for intense workouts or frequent notifications, you may want to consider the Withings ScanWatch for its longer battery life.

Both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and Withings ScanWatch use high-quality materials in their construction. The Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 uses aluminum or titanium and sapphire crystal glass, while the Withings ScanWatch uses 316L stainless steel and sapphire glass.

These materials are scratch-resistant and durable, ensuring that the watches can withstand daily wear and tear. The Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 is MIL-STD-810H certified, which means it has passed military-grade durability tests. The Withings ScanWatch, on the other hand, has a scratch-resistant sapphire crystal that protects the watch face from scratches and cracks.

The use of premium-grade materials in the Withings ScanWatch also gives it an elegant and versatile look, suitable for formal events. The 316L stainless steel used in the watch's construction is known for its corrosion resistance and durability. The sapphire glass used in the watch face is also highly scratch-resistant, ensuring that the watch remains in pristine condition for years to come.

Overall, both watches use high-quality materials that contribute to their durability and overall quality. Whether you choose the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 or the Withings ScanWatch, you can be sure that you are getting a watch that is built to last.

Both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and the Withings ScanWatch come in two sizes and have different materials for their cases and bands. The Galaxy Watch 5 has an aluminum bezel and a silicon band, while the ScanWatch has a stainless steel case and a fluoroelastomer wristband.

In terms of comfort, both watches have received positive reviews. The Galaxy Watch 5 sits comfortably on the wrist and is lightweight, with a snug fit that makes it comfortable to wear for extended periods of time. The silicon band is also comfortable to wear for 24+ hours at a time.

The ScanWatch has also been praised for its comfort, with a generous fluoroelastomer wristband that is durable and less likely to pick up lint than silicone bands. However, some reviewers have noted that they would not want to wear the ScanWatch at night, suggesting that it may not be as comfortable for extended periods of wear as the Galaxy Watch 5.

Overall, both watches have solid build quality and are comfortable to wear for hours on end. The choice between the two may come down to personal preference in terms of design and features.

In terms of display, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 appears to have a superior display compared to the Withings ScanWatch. The Galaxy Watch 5 has a larger and brighter Super AMOLED display with a higher resolution, making it easier to read and view information. The colors are also more vibrant and the ambient light sensor adjusts the brightness for optimal viewing.

Additionally, the sapphire crystal glass display provides better scratch resistance, making it more durable. This is a significant advantage for those who lead an active lifestyle and may expose their watch to potential damage. The added durability ensures that the watch can withstand wear and tear, making it a more reliable option in the long run.

On the other hand, the Withings ScanWatch has a smaller display and we don't have specific details on its brightness, clarity, and overall visual appeal. While it may still be a decent display, it may not be as impressive as the Galaxy Watch 5's display. This could be a drawback for those who prioritize a high-quality display for their smartwatch.

Overall, if display quality is a priority, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 may be the better choice. Its larger, brighter, and more durable display makes it a more attractive option for those who want a smartwatch that can keep up with their active lifestyle. However, if display quality is not a top priority, the Withings ScanWatch may still be a viable option for those who want a reliable and functional smartwatch.

Both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and Withings ScanWatch offer a range of bands and straps that can be easily interchanged. The Galaxy Watch 5 has a wider range of options, including sports bands, leather bands, and a Milanese band.

The straps are standard 20mm straps that can be easily switched out for another. The straps are comfortable to wear, and the quick-release pins at the back of the watch make it easy to swap out bands.

The Withings ScanWatch also offers a range of bands and straps, including metallic Milanese straps, leather straps, and FKM straps. The FKM strap that comes with the watch is comfortable to wear and looks classy.

The leather straps are also comfortable to wear, and the metallic Milanese strap looks stylish but may not be as comfortable as the FKM or leather straps. Overall, both watches offer a range of options for users to choose from based on their preferences and needs.

Overall, both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and Withings ScanWatch have their own unique and attractive designs. The Galaxy Watch 5 has a more modern and sleek look with its flat digital bezel and aluminum construction. It has a minimalist design that is perfect for those who prefer a more futuristic and techy look.

The watch is available in a variety of colors, including black, silver, and rose gold, making it easy to find one that matches your personal style.

On the other hand, the Withings ScanWatch has a classic and sophisticated appearance with its analog hands and sapphire glass and stainless steel construction. It has a timeless design that is perfect for those who prefer a traditional watch design. The watch is available in two sizes, 38mm and 42mm, and comes with interchangeable bands, allowing you to customize the look of your watch to match your outfit or mood.

In terms of which one has a more stylish look, it ultimately depends on personal preference. The Galaxy Watch 5 may appeal more to those who prefer a more futuristic and techy look, while the Withings ScanWatch may appeal more to those who prefer a traditional watch design. However, both watches have received positive reviews for their aesthetics and are considered stylish in their own right.

Overall, both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and Withings ScanWatch are excellent choices for anyone looking for a stylish and functional smartwatch. They both offer a range of features, including fitness tracking, heart rate monitoring, and smartphone notifications, making them perfect for anyone who wants to stay connected and active.

Whether you prefer a modern or traditional design, both watches are sure to impress with their stylish and functional designs.

While the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 offers a wide range of preinstalled apps and access to popular third-party apps through the Play Store, the Withings ScanWatch focuses on working seamlessly with the Health Mate app.

The Health Mate app provides clear and concise information about daily activity and general health, and allows for syncing with other health apps.

The Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 may be a better option for those who want a wider range of apps readily available on their watch, while the Withings ScanWatch may be a better option for those who prioritize seamless integration with a specific health app.

Both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and Withings ScanWatch have dedicated phone apps that allow users to manage and sync their smartwatches with their phones. The Galaxy Wearable app for the Samsung watch is necessary for synchronization and allows users to manage content in the Music and Gallery apps on the watch.

The app selection is limited, but it is easy to use and intuitive. On the other hand, the Health Mate app for the Withings watch is excellent, offering clear and concise information about daily activity and general health. It connects instantly to the ScanWatch and provides useful insights into everything the watch measures.

However, gaining insights and advice takes time and effort, making it a more user-intensive aspect of ownership. Overall, both apps have their strengths and weaknesses, but the Health Mate app for the Withings ScanWatch seems to offer more comprehensive health insights.

Both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and Withings ScanWatch are easy to connect to your smartphone. The Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 requires you to download the Galaxy Wearable app on your Android smartphone, while the Withings ScanWatch requires you to download the Withings Health Mate app from the App Store or Google Play Store.

Both apps are easy to use and guide you through the setup process. However, it's worth noting that the Galaxy Watch 5 is designed to work best with Samsung smartphones, while the Withings ScanWatch is compatible with both Android and iOS devices.

Overall, both watches are easy to connect to your smartphone, and the process is straightforward and quick. Whether you have an Android or iOS device, you can easily connect your watch and start using its features. With the help of the respective apps, you can customize your watch settings, track your fitness goals, and receive notifications on your wrist.

The ease of connectivity is a significant advantage of these smartwatches, making them accessible to a wide range of users.

In terms of Wi-Fi connectivity, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 has an advantage over the Withings ScanWatch. The Galaxy Watch 5 allows you to connect to Wi-Fi networks for internet access, while the ScanWatch does not have Wi-Fi connectivity.

However, the ScanWatch does have Bluetooth 4.0 to connect to your phone, which the Galaxy Watch 5 also has. This means that both watches can receive notifications, calls, and messages from your phone without the need for Wi-Fi.

Overall, if Wi-Fi connectivity is important to you, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 would be the better choice. It allows you to access the internet and use apps without needing to be connected to your phone. However, if you don't need Wi-Fi and prefer a watch that focuses on health and fitness tracking, the Withings ScanWatch may be a better fit for you.

When it comes to connectivity to other devices, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 stands out as the clear winner. This smartwatch boasts Bluetooth connectivity, which enables you to connect it to other devices such as headphones or speakers. You can even play music directly from the watch, making it a convenient option for those who enjoy listening to music while on the go.

In contrast, the Withings ScanWatch does not have this capability. It can only connect to your phone via Bluetooth for data syncing and notifications. While this may be sufficient for some users, those who want more versatility in terms of connectivity may find the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 to be a better option.

Overall, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5's Bluetooth connectivity is a significant advantage that sets it apart from the Withings ScanWatch. It allows for greater flexibility and convenience when it comes to connecting to other devices, making it a more versatile and functional smartwatch.

In terms of compatibility, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 is limited to Android devices only, while the Withings ScanWatch is compatible with both iOS and Android devices. This means that users who have an iPhone or iPad can still use the Withings ScanWatch, while the Galaxy Watch 5 is only available to Android users.

However, the Galaxy Watch 5 offers more features when paired with Samsung devices, such as ECG measurements. This means that users who have a Samsung phone or tablet can take advantage of this feature, which is not available on the Withings ScanWatch.

On the other hand, the Withings ScanWatch can be easily connected to other Withings devices through the Health Mate app, providing a more comprehensive health tracking experience. This means that users who have other Withings devices, such as a smart scale or blood pressure monitor, can easily sync their data and get a more complete picture of their health.

Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on the user's device preference and desired features. If they have a Samsung device and want to take advantage of the ECG feature, the Galaxy Watch 5 may be the better choice. However, if they have other Withings devices and want a more comprehensive health tracking experience, the Withings ScanWatch may be the better option.

Overall, both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and Withings ScanWatch have reliable connections with other devices. The Galaxy Watch 5 has minor improvements in Bluetooth connectivity and delivers notifications on time, while also allowing for music streaming and call management. This makes it a great option for those who want a traditional smartwatch experience with added features.

On the other hand, the Withings ScanWatch has a stable and simple connection process, but may not have all the features of a traditional smartwatch. It is designed more for health and fitness tracking, with features such as ECG monitoring and sleep tracking. Ultimately, the choice between these two smartwatches may depend on the user's specific needs and preferences.

If someone is looking for a more comprehensive smartwatch experience, the Galaxy Watch 5 may be the better option. However, if someone prioritizes health and fitness tracking, the Withings ScanWatch may be the better choice.

In terms of compatibility, the Withings ScanWatch has an advantage over the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 as it is compatible with both iOS and Android devices. The Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 is exclusive to Android phones and is not compatible with iOS-powered devices.

However, it is important to note that the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 has a more advanced operating system, One UI Watch 4.5, which is based on Google's Wear OS 3.5, compared to the Withings ScanWatch.

Additionally, the Withings ScanWatch syncs its data to the companion Health Mate app, which is compatible with over 100 other services, including Apple Health, Google Fit, MyFitnessPal, IFTTT, and even Fitbit, providing users with a wider range of options to track their health and fitness data.

Ultimately, the choice between the two devices will depend on the user's device preferences and the features they prioritize.

Both the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 and Withings ScanWatch can connect to smartphones and tablets. However, there are some differences in terms of device compatibility.

The Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 is exclusive to Android phones, which means that non-Samsung Android phones may not be able to access all features. This can be a limitation for users who do not own a Samsung phone.

On the other hand, the Withings ScanWatch offers more flexibility in terms of device compatibility. It can connect to both iOS and Android devices via the Withings Health Mate app. This means that users can use the watch with a wider range of devices, regardless of the brand.

Overall, the device compatibility of the Withings ScanWatch is more versatile than that of the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5. This can be an important factor for users who want to use the watch with different devices or switch between devices in the future.

In terms of compatibility, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 has some limitations as it only works with Android devices and requires a Samsung phone to access all features. On the other hand, the Withings ScanWatch is compatible with both iOS and Android devices and can work alongside other Withings devices to provide a comprehensive health tracking experience.

Therefore, if you have other Withings devices or prefer to use an iPhone, the Withings ScanWatch may be a better option for you. However, if you are an Android user and prefer Samsung phones, the Galaxy Watch 5 may be a better fit.