Comparing Bowflex Max Trainer M8 and Nautilus E618

Lowest price found: $1899 Show listings
Lowest price found: $2197 Show listings
Consumer Score
In comparison:
Bowflex Max Trainer M8 ranks #6 out of 58. Very high levels of customer satisfaction.
Go to rankings
9.1
Great
Consumer Score
In comparison:
Nautilus E618 ranks #31 out of 58.
Go to rankings
6.7
Good
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews

Experts prefer Nautilus E618 over Bowflex Max Trainer M8

On 7 Mar 2023 (25 days ago) we went through 83 Elliptical Trainer expert endorsements .

Currently, Nautilus E618 received 6 endorsements from CNET (1 Mar 2023), TopTenReviews (18 Feb 2022) Chicago Tribune (1 Feb 2023) and 3 others. Meanwhile, Bowflex Max Trainer M8 did not receive any endorsements this month.

Rank Change Price Elliptical Trainer
Woman's World
CNET
TopTenReviews
T3
Chicago Tribune
money.com
Forbes
NBC News
Treadmill Review Guru
Byrdie
2
- $2197
Nautilus E618
-
5
6
-
3
-
1
6
-
8
N/A N/A $1899
Bowflex Max Trainer M8
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-

Curious to see this month's entire Elliptical Trainers ranking? It's here

About our ranking methodology

Endorsement summary:

  • On 1 Mar 2023 CNET ranked Nautilus E618 as #5
    Rank Elliptical Trainer Comment
    ... ... ...
    #5 out of 6 Nautilus E618
    Most classic elliptical
    ... ... ...
  • On 18 Feb 2022 TopTenReviews ranked Nautilus E618 as #6
    Rank Elliptical Trainer Comment
    ... ... ...
    #6 out of 8 Nautilus E618
    Best Elliptical Machine For Guided Workouts
    ... ... ...
  • On 1 Feb 2023 Chicago Tribune ranked Nautilus E618 as #3
    Rank Elliptical Trainer Comment
    ... ... ...
    #3 out of 5 Nautilus E618
    Best For Everyday Use
    ... ... ...
  • On 21 Nov 2022 Forbes ranked Nautilus E618 as #1
    Rank Elliptical Trainer Comment
    #1 out of 8 Nautilus E618
    Best Elliptical Overall
    ... ... ...
  • On 30 Sep 2022 NBC News ranked Nautilus E618 as #6
    Rank Elliptical Trainer
    ... ...
    #6 out of 10 Nautilus E618
    ... ...
  • On 2 Feb 2023 Byrdie ranked Nautilus E618 as #8
    Rank Elliptical Trainer Comment
    ... ... ...
    #8 out of 11 Nautilus E618
    Best App-Based
    ... ... ...
Made up your mind? Ready to dive in?

Customers like Bowflex Max Trainer M8 way more

At ReviewFinder we prefer to focus on professional product reviews, because customer reviews can be disproportionately affected by unrelated factors such as delivery, specific seller listing problems, and, of course, fake reviews. With that said, below is the summary of consumer sentiment.

Bowflex Max Trainer M8
Nautilus E618
Consumer score (CS) is a normalized computed representation of customers' sentiment towards a product.
CS of 10 is similar to a 4.8 star review, CS of 0 is similar to a 2 star review.

Bowflex Max Trainer M8, the cheaper option, tends to get more favorable reviews than Nautilus E618.

As can be seen in the chart above, median best-selling elliptical trainer receives a consumer score of 7.0 (good). Bowflex Max Trainer M8 ranks higher than that and Nautilus E618 ranks lower than that.

Bowflex Max Trainer M8
In comparison:
Bowflex Max Trainer M8 ranks #6 out of 58. Very high levels of customer satisfaction.
Go to rankings
9.1
Great
Nautilus E618
In comparison:
Nautilus E618 ranks #31 out of 58.
Go to rankings
6.7
Good
Median best-selling Elliptical Trainer
In comparison:
Body Champ Trio Trainer Plus 2 ranks #30 out of 58.
Go to rankings
7.0
Good





Bowflex Max Trainer M8 is more popular than Nautilus E618

It's fairly safe to say that Bowflex Max Trainer M8 is a more popular elliptical trainer than Nautilus E618, based on its 1,000+ reviews. Popularity is determined based on product sales. Note that older and cheaper products tend to sell more.


To consider

Customers who view Bowflex Max Trainer M8 and Nautilus E618 often consider Nautilus E618, a pricier option.
Table: Top compared alternatives for Bowflex Max Trainer M8 and Nautilus E618
Nautilus E618 $2197
In comparison:
Nautilus E618 ranks #31 out of 58.
Go to rankings
6.7
Good
6 expert recommendations
Teeter FreeStep LT1 $1540
In comparison:
Teeter FreeStep LT1 ranks #8 out of 58. Very high levels of customer satisfaction.
Go to rankings
9.0
Great
No expert recommendations Cheaper
NordicTrack FreeStrider FS10i $2739
We don't yet have enough review information for NordicTrack FreeStrider FS10i
N/A
3 expert recommendations
Horizon Fitness EX 59 $1100
In comparison:
Horizon Fitness EX 59 ranks #42 out of 58.
Go to rankings
6.0
Average
2 expert recommendations Cheaper
Find the best elliptical trainer in Elliptical Trainer Finder
Critic Consensus Common points from expert reviews summarized.
As can be seen below, Nautilus E618 is mentioned by key experts in Mar 2023, while Bowflex Max Trainer M8 is not.
Rank Change Price Elliptical Trainer
Woman's World
CNET
TopTenReviews
T3
Chicago Tribune
money.com
Forbes
NBC News
Treadmill Review Guru
Byrdie
1
- $1099
Schwinn 470
-
4
8
-
1
-
-
5
-
1
2
- $2197
Nautilus E618
-
5
6
-
3
-
1
6
-
8
3
- Check price
Sunny Health & Fitness SF-E905
1
-
-
-
-
2
5
4
-
2
4
- $900
Sole Fitness E25
-
-
7
7
-
1
-
1
-
-
Show all rows
Expert Reviews There are people on the Internet whose job is to review products. Below are their opinions.
No expert reviews linked yet for Bowflex Max Trainer M8.

Expert reviews [17]

86
Total expert reviews: 17
  • with a score: 7
  • without a score: 10
Highest score by SmartReview
92
Average score based on 17 reviews
86
Lowest score by Elliptical Review Guru
70

Score distribution:

80-100
60-80
40-60
20-40
0-20
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews
From Seller:
  • Introducing Bowflex JRNY, the personalized coaching technology that integrates with your M8 to create daily, custom workouts that automatically adjust time and intensity as your fitness improves. (JRNY App subscription required.)
  • Read more
From Seller:
  • Your purchase includes One Nautilus Elliptical Trainer E618
  • Elliptical dimensions: 27" W x 73" L x 67" H | Item weight – 210 lbs. | Weight Capacity: 350 lbs. | Ceiling height clearance – Consider the height of the tallest potential user, and add 21 inches minimum
  • Read more
Video Reviews Most popular unboxing/review videos.
No video reviews linked yet for Bowflex Max Trainer M8.
Nautilus E616 - Best Elliptical Review
Review by Gadget Jungle Pro
Play video review
From Manufacturer Manufacturer-provided product description, urls and documents.
EAN Numbers: 0708447913364
UPC Numbers: 708447913364
EAN Numbers: 0708447911070
Model Numbers: 100656
UPC Numbers: 708447911070
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews
Physical Features
Weight
no data Know this info? Contribute!

209 lbs
 
Dimensions Ellipticals range from 4 feet long (1.2m) to 7 feet long (2.1m) and 4 feet high (1.2m) to 5+ feet high (1.7m). The most important thing to consider is the space in which you plan to place the elliptic ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Loading product dimensions...
Location of Flywheel Flywheels can be front-drive, rear-drive, or center-drive. In a front-drive flywheel, the wheel that powers the pedals is located in the front of the machine below the console and handlebars. Front-dr ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Front
Flywheel Weight The heaviest part of an elliptical is the flywheel. They weigh anywhere from 13-30 pounds (5.8kg to 13.6kg), with basic models averaging 15 pounds (6.8kg). Generally speaking, the heavier the flywheel ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
30 lbs
Maximum User Weight Every elliptical has a weight restriction based on the machines capacity for use. Weight limits range from 250-350 pounds (113kg to 159kg), though most hover around the 300-pound mark. As a general ru ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
350 lbs
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews
Stride and Incline
Maximum Stride Length Stride length describes the distance the pedals cover from front to back when you “run.” It ranges from 12” to 21” (30cm to 53cm). The length you need will depend on the height of the user. If you hav ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
1.7 ft
Adjustable Stride An adjustable stride allows you change the distance your feet move from front to back while using the elliptical. This can be useful if you have several users of different heights that plan to exercis ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
No
Reverse Stride Reversible stride ellipticals allow you to essentially run backwards while exercising. This is best for targeting different muscle groups. Running forwards mainly works your quadriceps, upper body and ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Type of Incline Inclining the elliptical allows you to raise the front of the pedals or tracks to simulate running uphill, which leads to a tougher workout and exercising different muscle groups. Inclining can be don ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Automatic
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews
Capacity and Handling
Type of Resistance Resistance describes the level of effort it takes to move the pedals back and forth along the track. The higher the resistance (or pressure against movement), the tougher the workout. Ellipticals come ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Automatic
Wheels Some ellipticals will have wheels on the front or back of the base, so you can tip the machine and roll it to a different spot in your home. This is especially useful if you want to transport the elli ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Foldable A folding elliptical can be reduced in size for easy storage by folding elements up or inward. This is especially helpful if you need a machine that doesn’t take up a lot of space. The drawbacks to a ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
No
Hybrid Machine Hybrid machines can be an elliptical-bike or an elliptical-stair stepper. An elliptical-bike has a seat built onto the base, so you can sit down to use the machine as an exercise bike or stand up on t ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Elliptical
Movable Handles While using an elliptical, you can place your hands on the vertical handles on either side of the console. These handles can be stationary or movable. Stationary handles are common in less expensive m ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews
Heart Rate Tracking and Programs
Heart Rate Monitor Does the elliptical include heart rate monitors on the handles?
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Chest strap
Location of Heart Rate Monitors Ellipticals can support heart rate monitoring in several ways. First, there could be metal heart rate monitors on the stationary handles under the console or on each side of the console (or both). Bec ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Stationary Handles
Progress Tracking In order to keep a log of your workouts and stats, such as time, distance traveled, calories burned, etc., you may want an elliptical that does this for you automatically. Some machines come with auto ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Number of Workout Programs Preprogrammed workouts on ellipticals guide you through an activity focused on a certain goal or type of workout. Examples range from hill climb, where the elliptical automatically adjusts incline and ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
29
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews
Display Screen

Elliptical displays offer a wide range of features that vary greatly from one machine to another. The display can be as simple as analog LED lights that show time and distance traveled or as complex as a fully functioning TV screen with cable network connectivity. Displays vary in size and type, with higher end machines displaying more stats (time, distance, incline, speed, heart rate, workout program status, etc.) and offering more advanced features (such as a virtual tour that simulates traveling through real-life environments). There are positives and negatives to this level of complexity. On the plus side, sophisticated displays allow you to easily monitor and adjust your workout based on the information presented. They may also provide a distraction from the dull pace of elliptical exercise. At the same time, this kind of distraction can be harmful to your workout because it may cause you to fall or injure yourself or be overly conscious of the clock and distance.

Advanced display screens or TV screens could have the added benefit of linking with your smartphone, so you can watch video content on the display as you run. The suite of features will be dependent on your needs but know that you’ll pay significantly more for complex displays and TV screens.

Display Screen Does the elliptical console have a screen?
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Type of Display
no data Know this info? Contribute!
LCD
2 STN blue backlit LCDs
Media/TV Capabilities Can the elliptical’s screen play TV or media, such as movies?
no data Know this info? Contribute!
No
Metrics Displayed What metrics are displayed on the elliptical console/screen?
no data Know this info? Contribute!
  • Time
  • Speed
  • Distance
  • RPM
  • Resistance level
  • Calories burned
  • Heart rate
  • Workout program profiles
  • Selected goal
  • Progress
Touch Screen Is the display touch screen?
no data Know this info? Contribute!
No
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews
Dashboard
The elliptical dashboard can have a number of useful features. A device shelf allows you to place your smartphone or tablet on the dashboard, so you can use your device—safely—while you work out. Yes, that means watching Netflix or reading an ebook!


Similiar to the device shelf is the water bottle holder. This may seem insignificant, but believe it or not, the placement of the water bottle holder can have a huge impact on the productivity of your workout. You want your water bottle to be within arm’s reach, so you don’t have to stop to grab a drink.

Finally, some ellipticals come with a built-in fan on the dashboard, which is great for some added comfort while you exercise.

Water Bottle Holder
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Device Shelf For holding your smartphone, tablet, or other media device.
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Built-In Fan Does the elliptical console include a fan?
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews
Console Extras
USB Charging Port If the elliptical has a USB port, you’ll likely be able to charge your smartphone or tablet, which is great for long workouts. If you like to watch TV or listen to music, this can help save battery, t ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Headphone Jack An auxiliary port or headphone jack lets you connect your smartphone or tablet directly to the elliptical’s media system to listen to sound directly through its speakers, so that you don’t have to get ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Built-In Speakers Some ellipticals have speakers built into the dashboard. Through Bluetooth or a basic auxiliary cable, you can connect your phone or media device to the machine’s console to play music, listen to podc ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Mobile App Connectivity Some elliptical companies also have proprietary mobile applications (such as Schwinn Connect, LifeSpan’s Activ Trac, Nautilus Trainer, etc.) that extend the features of the machine. This can include a ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
App Subscription Cost Some ellipticals will require a monthly or yearly subscription cost to access certain features. This might include advanced progress tracking, additional workout programs or syncing with a brand-speci ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Free
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews
Software Features
Sync with Third Party Apps Can you sync workout data with third part apps, such as MyFitnessPal and FitBit?
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Compatible Apps If you’re using a fitness app such as Google Fit, MyFitnessPal, or FitBit, some smart ellipticals allow users to transfer their workout details from the elliptical’s tracking system directly your favo ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
  • Nautilus Trainer
  • Nautilus Connect
  • MyFitnessPal
  • RunSocial
Bluetooth Connectivity Ellipticals that are Bluetooth capable can connect wirelessly with your Bluetooth-enabled smartphone or tablet. This is most commonly used to play music on the elliptical’s speakers. Some ellipticals ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
Yes
Wi-Fi Connectivity Ellipticals that are Wi-Fi enabled can connect to your home wireless network for enhanced features. This could include syncing with or data transfer to external devices, such as a smartphone, computer ... Show more
no data Know this info? Contribute!
No
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews
Warranty

Ellipticals separate their warranties into four sections: Frame, Parts, Labor and Brake System. Across all of these categories, warranties are an important feature to assess in ellipticals because the length of the warranties are an indication of the company’s confidence in the machines ability to last. 90-day warranties show that the manufacturer doesn’t believe the elliptical hold up past the first 90 days of ownership.

Frame warranties should be lifetime warranties. Anything less than that is an indication of a cheaply made machine and buyers should be wary.

Parts warranties range from 90 days to 5 years to lifetime warranties. For light use, 90 days to 1 year might be an acceptable parts warranty, though you should not expect that machine to be extremely durable.

Labor warranties range from 90 days to 3 years. For light or moderate use, choose an elliptical with at least 1-year labor warranty. If you plan to use the machine long and often, it’d be best to find a labor warranty of 2-3 years. Note that labor warranties are typically shorter than parts warranties, which means that, up until a certain point, the company will cover the cost of parts, but not the cost of paying someone to fix it. 

Finally, like the frame warranty, the best brands offer you a lifetime warranty on the brake system, which provides resistance on the elliptical. If you have an electromagnetic brake system, you likely won’t have any issues, but it always helps to have reassurance that you’re covered if something goes wrong.

Parts Warranty What is the parts warranty for this elliptical?
no data Know this info? Contribute!
5 years
Labor Warranty
no data Know this info? Contribute!
2 years
Frame Warranty What is the warranty on the frame alone?
no data Know this info? Contribute!
15 years
Brake System Warranty
no data Know this info? Contribute!
5 years
Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews
Loading price comparison chart...

Bowflex Max Trainer M8 is a very popular option on the higher end of the price range. It's in the top 3 bestselling elliptical trainers and has a couple of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as ProForm Pro 9.9 or Teeter FreeStep LT1 .

Bowflex Max Trainer M8 is $999.01 more expensive than the average elliptical trainer ($899.99).

Nautilus E618 is a very popular option at the top of the price range. It's in the top 3 bestselling elliptical trainers and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as Octane Q35x or ProForm Pro HIIT H14 .

Nautilus E618 is $1297.01 more expensive than the average elliptical trainer ($899.99).

Bowflex Max Trainer M8: Buy | Customer Reviews
Nautilus E618: Buy | Customer Reviews

You might also like:

High-rated Elliptical Trainers in a similar price range.

This website displays data from third party public sources. The data presented is for information purposes only. We can't guarantee correctness and completeness of all the data presented here, and therefore will not accept liability for any issues arising from usage of this data. All Trademarks and Copyrights belong to their respective owners. ReviewFinder is reader-supported - if you click on a link on ReviewFinder and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you.


Copyright © 2023